The UP Files Movie Review : Ambitious themes lost in a formulaic, disjointed narrative
- 29 Jul 2024 12:00 AM
- 173 views
Story: Inspired by true events, The UP Files chronicles the journey of Abhay Singh (Manoj Joshi), Uttar Pradesh's newly elected Chief Minister, who is determined to transform the state through effective governance. Confronting the land mafia, criminals, and corrupt officials, Singh is committed to advancing women's welfare and promoting equitable justice, regardless of religion.
Review: Directed by Neeraj Sahai, The UP Files aims to reframe Uttar Pradesh's reputation, highlighting a shift from lawlessness to progressive governance under Chief Minister Abhay Singh. The film showcases Singh’s bold initiatives, such as empowering rape survivors to seek justice, relocating corrupt bureaucrats to rural areas, and focusing on village electrification to generate employment. Additionally, it advocates for a unified legal framework applicable to all citizens, irrespective of religion, caste, or class.
Despite its ambitious goals, the film falters in delivering a cohesive narrative. It champions a 'no discussion, only action' approach with controversial solutions that detract from its effectiveness. Writer Stanish Gill’s script and screenplay are plagued by clichéd elements and a disjointed presentation reminiscent of 90s Bollywood. The film features familiar tropes like violated women seeking justice and a courageous female cop, Sujata Menon (Manjari Fadnnis), who battles both criminals and corrupt colleagues.
Though the film addresses thought-provoking themes such as personal freedom and the necessity of a unified legal system, its lack of a structured storyline and poor editing dilute its message. The music is forgettable, with songs that begin and end abruptly, and the film's conclusion feels rushed.
Manoj Joshi delivers a commendable performance as the Chief Minister, effectively portraying his dedication to the state’s welfare. Manjari Fadnnis also performs earnestly but struggles with action sequences. The cast includes Milind Gunaji, Ali Asgar, Anil George, and Amam Verma, but their performances are overshadowed by the film’s narrative flaws.
Overall, The UP Files misses the mark by failing to create a compelling story and relying on formulaic tropes. Despite its earnest attempt to explore important themes and advocate for effective leadership, the film’s shortcomings undermine its potential impact.
