Kamala Harris’s Indian heritage seemed like it would easily win over Indian-American voters, a group that traditionally supports Democrats. But in the 2024 election, many in this community moved toward Donald Trump, helping him secure a big victory. This shift reflects what’s happening across the country: voters want leaders focused on economic stability, safety, and family values, not just social issues.

Recent polls show the change clearly. From 2020 to 2024, Indian-Americans identifying as Democrats dropped from 56% to 47%, while support for Trump rose from 22% to 31%. Young Indian-American men, in particular, led this shift, rejecting Democratic policies they feel ignore real-world priorities.

Many Indian-Americans are frustrated with the Democrats’ focus on progressive social agendas. They value hard work, education, and family unity—things they feel the Democrats no longer emphasize. Instead, they’re drawn to practical solutions that address economic growth and security.

Even Harris’s connection to her Indian roots hasn’t helped. Some feel her representation of Indian culture lacks depth and meaning, especially compared to leaders like Vivek Ramaswamy, who openly embrace their heritage.

Immigration is another sore spot. Indian-Americans who followed the legal process to settle in the U.S. often support merit-based immigration and feel Democrats are too lenient on illegal immigration. Many are upset that skilled workers remain stuck in backlogs while undocumented immigrants get benefits and jobs.

Foreign policy has also caused concern. The Biden administration’s support for Canadian Prime Minister Justin Trudeau on Sikh separatist issues has alienated Indian-Americans who value India’s sovereignty and security. This adds to broader fears that Democrats are weak on global threats.

The Democratic focus on diversity and inclusion (DEI) policies has also drawn criticism. Many Indian-Americans feel these efforts prioritize identity over critical issues like jobs, education, and safety.

With over 4.8 million Indian-Americans in key states, both parties are trying to win their support. For Democrats, this means they must move beyond symbolic gestures and focus on addressing real concerns. Indian-Americans, like all voters, want leaders who deliver results, not just promises.